Who am I? I am an introvert, a lover of books, a chef, a grad student, a classicist, a musician, a humanist, a computer nerd, a gamer, a friend, a spouse, a family member, and above all your fellow human being. I also happen to be a Mormon who identifies as transgender. While this blog might be primarily about those last two facts, I would hate for you, dear reader, to define me solely by those final attributes. And I would hate to define myself solely in terms of my gender. It would be rather easy to let my gender issues control my life, and frankly too often they do. So hopefully the content of this blog will reflect many of the diverse aspects of my personality, my likes, my interests, and who I am, not merely the fact that I identify as transgender.
I find myself in the unenviable, but all too common, position of being absolutely clueless and I will freely admit that I do not know how to cope with gender dysphoria. All too often, as I discuss the issue with others, I am given two distinct answers as solutions to my dilemma. On the one hand, I am told that transitioning gender (or publicly changing my gender presentation) is an effective way (and perhaps the only way) to stop the dysphoria (and frankly there is a lot of evidence supporting this effectiveness). On the other hand, I hear that I ought to do nothing. By suppressing the dysphoria and being a little stronger, I will save my family, my wife and my friends a great deal of heartache and confusion.
So what am I to do? In so many ways I would love to transition (even if just socially). On some days, when the pain of my gender dysphoria is overwhelming, transitioning seems like the only reasonable option. I have no idea how effective transition would be (both in reducing the gender dysphoria and allowing me to fit into society), or what affects such an action would have on my life (I don't think that can be truly understood by anyone until after they transition). Even with all the unknowns it is an enticing answer.
Yet as I think about transition I wonder about all the pain and anguish that I might cause to those around me by making such a decision. I have a wonderful wife and my relationship with her is the single greatest and most precious gift that I have. I think about how much pain and anguish this has already caused her and wonder how much more pain she can take. I question the morality of the situation. What right do I have to cause her pain even if my own pain lessens? I look at my family and friends and wonder what right I have to cause them pain? I've been told that watching someone transition is almost like watching the person you know and love die and watching a new person be born. I've watched how even the smallest disturbances of gendered norms make some of my family and friends deeply uncomfortable. How would it make them feel if I shattered those norms? How many relationships would I deeply damage?
I'm not a saint: it's not only the morality of the situation that concerns me. I'm afraid. I'm not the almost emotionally stalwart individual and, to throw a little Freud into the conversation, I'm extremely susceptible to the superego--societal pressures, fear of rejection from anyone (even random strangers on the street), and fear of conflict all make me conform to society on a regular basis. I like a carefully planned-out and stable life. And the final state of my life after transition is unknowable.
So I remain sitting on the fence. The emotional damage that I would inflict upon my family and friends by transitioning would be an unacceptable loss. The damage that I would inflict upon my wife would probably be even greater. But the emotional damage I inflict upon myself by doing nothing (and this emotional damage certainly affects my wife as well) is also unacceptable. So I find myself constantly searching for other alternatives. Often trying new things, and often watching them fail. But I'm trying to find an answer where everyone can be happy. I often feel like Don Quixote charging at windmills in a foolish impossible endeavor; a gradual madness that consumes my life. But surely attempting to find the path where I cause the least pain is a commendable task.
I would be remiss in introducing myself if I did not give my better half credit. I am fortunate that I am married to the most wonderful wife in the whole world. Now dear reader, you may contest this fact. And I will let you contest, and argue, and debate the issue until your face turns blue, but it will all be for naught. It is an incontestable truth that I am married to the most amazing individual on the planet. She has been there through the thick and thin of all of my troubles; helping me come out to myself, helping me understand what gender dysphoria was, helping me begin to come to grips with how I should live with gender dysphoria, and helping me come out to my closest friends and family. Much of the credit for who I am today goes to her.
Oh wow, this is amazing. You put it into words! That feeling of "do I transition and lose my family, or do I not transition and risk losing myself?"
ReplyDeleteI feel the same way about my husband that you do about your wife. I'm glad to know I'm not alone.
no matter who we are, we cannot separate ourselves from those we love, none of us are islands. Some rooms in the heart and brain may remain painful and undressed so that those rooms we share with others can remain warm and loving. It is also very painful for me not to be undergoing transition, it hurts everyday. But it would hurt more to hurt those I love, I just know this... I have a little bit of terror about what the resurrection will bring, but I know Christ knows us, feels what we feel, and will help. Thank you for your words. Lona.
ReplyDeleteThank you.
ReplyDeleteThank you.
ReplyDeleteFrom one trans Mormon to another, I wish you as much happiness as possible. I understand the feeling of feeling torn trying to balance your gender identity, church identity, and identity in social, family, and romantic relationships. It has been hard for me too, but I will be thinking of you and hoping that you can find the peace and happiness you deserve. You are beautiful and so brave! <3
ReplyDeleteI wish you well. I'm a trans woman, and was raised to be a Mormon man. I made a go of it for 40 years, but finally transitioned last year. I tried everything to "remain faithful," but the pain of it all took a terrible toll on my mental health. In the end, I transitioned in an attempt to save my life. I wasn't sure things would work out, but it has been going well over the past 8 months. I am at peace with myself for the first time in years. I wasn't sure I would have value as a woman, but I am now really grateful to be trans. I have finally come to accept myself for the first time in my life.
ReplyDeleteBeing trans is a unique challenge. I only have love for my trans sisters and brothers, whether they transition or not. I see you for who you are, appreciate your struggles, and love you.
I hope things work out for you! I echo Sparrow's comments - you are brave and beautiful (and strong).
I don't know if you still keep an eye on this blog, or if you even remember the troublemaker kid who ran away on a field trip to UVU. One of the kids you made pancakes for on Friday mornings, one of the kids you taught to cook during a winterim class.
ReplyDeleteI want you to know that you made a big impact in my life. I still enjoy cooking, and most of my practical knowledge about that was taught by you. I think I googled all my teachers sometime during eight grade, and came across this blog then. I never said anything, never knew what to think. I don't think I even knew what being trans was at the time. But I've thought about you often, thought about how much effort you were putting in for us kids.
I remember asking what the closest you ever came to dying was, and I remember how candid and honest of an answer you gave me. I didn't know what to think about that either, but I always remember that day whenever I need to open up about myself to someone else.
I wish I could talk to you in person, as weird as it is I wish I could give you a hug. So many of my core memories and personal traits were shaped at APA, and most of them weren't good. But you stood out.
You stood out, and taught me that it was okay to be different. You taught me it was possible to have all manner of inner turmoil and still put the best foot forward.
You taught me that it was wrong to make assumptions about people. I hated you at first. I hated you because of your wife, and I hated you for whatever it was that happened at UVU. And then I actually got to know you, and realized that I was so wrong to hate you that I've never been so quick to judge people ever since.
From the bottom of my heart, thank you. Thank you for teaching me to cook, and be vulnerable, and honest, and put my best foot forward when times are tough. Thank you for the "inference" assignments at the beginning of every class. Thank you for the pancakes that brought a glimmer of light into that terrible school. Thank you for being someone that I could be happy around.
This is my first attempt to contact you, I'm going to try and track down an email or something as well. You've made a bigger difference in my life than I think you ever imagined, and I want you to know that.